Scrutor is an effective addition to the Dependency Injection (DI) container that comes with.NET. Without taking the place of the default DI system, it makes assembly scanning, convention-based registration, and decorator support possible. Scrutor greatly saves boilerplate, but if used carelessly, it also adds indirection that can conceal architectural issues. The majority of Dependency Injection problems encountered in practical applications are not caused by Scrutor per se, but rather by excessively expansive scanning rules, ambiguous lifetimes, or hard-to-understand implicit registrations.

Using real-world, production-focused examples, this article examines the most frequent Dependency Injection errors while using Scrutor and discusses how to avoid them.
1. Over-Scanning Assemblies
The problem
Why does this cause issues
Scanning
all application dependencies registers every discoverable class,
including framework and third-party types. This makes the DI container
unpredictable, slows application startup, and creates behavior that is
difficult to debug and reason about.
The correct approach
Scan only assemblies you own and apply strict filters.
Assembly scanning should always be deliberate and narrowly scoped.
2. Accidental Multiple Interface Registrations
The problem
This registers every implemented interface, including interfaces that were never meant to be resolved from the container.
Why this is dangerous
Unintended registrations can override other services and introduce subtle bugs that appear only at runtime.
The correct approach
Be explicit when registering services that implement multiple interfaces.
Automatic interface registration should be used only when the intent is clear and controlled.
3. Lifetime Mismatch (Captive Dependency)
The problem
Why this breaks applications
A singleton capturing a scoped dependency leads to memory leaks, invalid object lifetimes, and runtime exceptions under load.
The correct approach
Align lifetimes so that dependencies live at least as long as their consumers.
Alternatively, use factory abstractions such as IDbContextFactory .
4. Hidden Decorators and Execution Order Confusion
The problem
What actually happens
The runtime execution order becomes:
Why this is confusing
Decorators
are invisible at injection sites, and the execution order is not
obvious. Changing the registration order can silently alter application
behavior.
The correct approach
Register decorators together, document their order, and add constructor logging in development to make resolution explicit.
Decorator order should always be intentional.
5. Mixing Manual and Scrutor Registrations
The problem
Why this leads to bugs
The
.NET DI container follows a last-registration-wins strategy. Mixing
manual and scanned registrations makes behavior unpredictable and
environment-dependent.
The correct approach
Use
one registration strategy per layer. Scrutor is well-suited for
application services and repositories, while manual registration should
be reserved for infrastructure and framework services.
Consistency is more important than flexibility.
6. Not Validating Dependency Injection at Startup
The problem
Dependency Injection errors surface only at runtime, often under load.
The correct approach
Enable DI validation during application startup.
This configuration catches missing registrations, circular dependencies, and lifetime mismatches early.
7. Business Logic Inside Decorators
The problem
Why this is a design flaw
Decorators
should not contain business rules. Hiding business logic inside
decorators makes behavior harder to understand, test, and maintain.
The correct approach
Decorators
should handle technical cross-cutting concerns such as logging,
caching, validation, or metrics. Business rules should remain in the
core service.
8. Overusing Singleton Services
The problem
Why this causes problems
Singletons
introduce shared mutable state, thread-safety issues, and test
instability. Many services do not need to live for the entire lifetime
of the application.
The correct approach
Default to scoped services unless there is a clear and justified reason to use a singleton.
Singletons should be rare and stateless.
9. Service Locator Usage in Minimal APIs
The problem
Why this is harmful
Manually
resolving services hides dependencies and reintroduces the service
locator anti-pattern, making the code harder to test and reason about.
The correct approach
Let the framework inject dependencies directly.
Mental Model to Remember
Scrutor
reduces boilerplate, but it also hides complexity. If your DI
configuration is difficult to explain, difficult to debug, or behaves
differently across environments, your scanning rules are too permissive.
Key Takeaway
Scrutor is not inherently dangerous. Uncontrolled conventions are.
When
used with tight assembly scanning, clear lifetimes, explicit intent,
and proper validation, Scrutor becomes a powerful tool for building
clean, scalable Dependency Injection in .NET.
Happy Coding!
I
write about modern C#, .NET, and real-world development practices.
Follow me on C# Corner for regular insights, tips, and deep dives.
Best ASP.NET Core 10.0 Hosting Recommendation
One of the most important things when choosing a good ASP.NET Core 8.0 hosting is the feature and reliability.
HostForLIFE
is the leading provider of Windows hosting and affordable ASP.NET Core, their
servers are optimized for PHP web applications. The performance and the uptime of the hosting service are excellent
and the features of the web hosting plan are even greater than what many
hosting providers ask you to pay for.
At HostForLIFEASP.NET, customers can also experience fast ASP.NET Core
hosting. The company invested a lot of money to ensure the best and fastest
performance of the datacenters, servers, network and other facilities. Its
datacenters are equipped with the top equipments like cooling system, fire
detection, high speed Internet connection, and so on. That is why
HostForLIFEASP.NET guarantees 99.9% uptime for ASP.NET Core. And the engineers do
regular maintenance and monitoring works to assure its Orchard hosting are
security and always up.